Selling TIFFANY FAQs

You can always resell authentic Tiffany & Co. jewelry in good condition without significant damage or issues.

Tiffany & Co. is one of the best brands for resale value. High-end design houses like Tiffany, Cartier, and Van Cleef & Arpels will always fetch more significant premiums when you resell them than regular non-designer signed jewelry. When selling Tiffany jewelry, one can expect to receive anywhere from 20% to 60% of the original retail purchase price. The amount will depend mainly on the item's desirability, as some older styles are no longer popular. 

Tiffany will accept returns within 30 days and offers a trade-in program, but they will not buy back their jewelry outright.

There are several reasons to sell your Tiffany jewelry. Usually, sellers have items they no longer wear because their style has changed over the years. Another reason to sell Tiffany jewelry is to sell items gifted from a previous partner. Often, someone will inherit Tiffany jewelry and decide to sell it. Lastly, selling your Tiffany jewelry can quickly raise much-needed funds if you need to raise money for an emergency expense.

First, see if you have the original certificate for the diamond and the original appraisal paperwork from Tiffany. If not, try contacting the store to see if they can provide you with a copy. This paperwork will help you and buyers learn the details of your Tiffany engagement ring. Once you have this critical information, contact several buyers for a preliminary value estimate. Remember that the condition of your ring will also affect its resale value. 

Diamond and gold or platinum pieces will have the most resale value. Also, items from Jean Schlumberger, Elsa Peretti, and Paloma Picasso tend to bring more money. Vintage and antique Tiffany & Co. engagement rings, diamond jewelry, and Ruby, Sapphire, and emerald jewelry will also get the highest resale value. Remember that newer items are in higher demand, while older, less popular collections can often bring minimal premium. And, of course, the higher the original retail price, the more money

Diamond and gold or platinum pieces will have the most resale value. Also, items from Jean Schlumberger, Elsa Peretti, and Paloma Picasso tend to bring more money. Vintage and antique Tiffany & Co. engagement rings, diamond jewelry, and Ruby, Sapphire, and emerald jewelry will also get the highest resale value. Remember that newer items are in higher demand, while older, less popular collections can often bring minimal premium. And, of course, the higher the original retail price, the more mon

If you have all your original paperwork, it will be easier to sell Tiffany jewelry because you can give this information to potential buyers and prove authenticity. Next, remember that location matters. You often find more local buyers in major cities, while rural areas offer fewer. Luckily, there are many choices available online. As long as you research to figure out a realistic resale value and contact a few reputable buyers, you will find that selling Tiffany jewelry is easy.

The best place to sell Tiffany jewelry is always to a buyer specializing in the brand. While almost any jewelry buyer will purchase Tiffany jewelry, the chances of getting the highest offer from just any buyer are low. Many stores, cash-for-gold shops, pawnshops, and others will only consider the scrap gold value for your Tiffany item. A buyer who understands the market for Tiffany & Co. will be most able to pay you more because he also knows how to get more for it.

Yes, you can sell Tiffany jewelry online on sites like eBay, Facebook Marketplace, or Etsy, but it takes more effort and time. You must write listings, take good photos, and wait for a buyer. Safety is key—meet in a secure place like a police station or bank.

You could also use a marketplace that lists and sells your items, but you still must ship them, wait for sales, and pay commissions.

A direct buyer like sell-tiffany.com pays upfront and offers top prices, so you avoid the waiting.

Yes, pawnshops usually buy Tiffany & Co. jewelry. However, few will pay extra for the Tiffany brand name and may only offer you scrap gold value for Tiffany jewelry. While not ideal, this could still be a good option if you need cash immediately. And if you do a little calling around, you may find a pawnshop willing to pay extra for Tiffany jewelry, as many of them will be able to resell Tiffany in their shops or online stores. If you want a loan on your Tiffany jewelry, a pawnshop is a great 

 Tiffany & Co. diamonds are always more valuable than regular diamonds. Although diamonds are diamonds, and there is nothing chemically different from a Tiffany diamond, Tiffany diamonds' quality is always the highest available and, therefore, worth more than average diamonds. But there are other reasons why Tiffany & Co. diamonds are always worth more. The main reason is the value of the brand itself. The little blue box is an iconic symbol of the best money can buy.

You can always resell Tiffany & Co. jewelry if you are up to the project, although it will usually be much more work. If you know a friend or family member who likes your item, this would be ideal for reselling your Tiffany jewelry. You can find a fair price by looking online to see what your item has recently been selling for and then simply working out a deal. The risk of working with a stranger is gone, and you can enjoy knowing that a friend or family member is now enjoying your item.

. The short answer is yes, you will likely lose a decent amount of money when selling your Tiffany jewelry. Please understand there will be a large gap between Tiffany's retail price and secondary market prices. When a person buys jewelry brand new from Tiffany & Co., part of what they are paying for is the confidence and security of buying directly and brand new from the company. They are also paying for the store experience, so they must accept the high retail price.